Court Finds Computer Use Policy May Violate First Amendment

The United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois recently decided that a university’s Computer Usage Policy may violate professors’ First Amendment right to free speech.  Objecting to a faculty-created blog that was often critical of university administration, Chicago State University sent a cease-and-desist letter to a faculty member, claiming that the blog lacked the “civility” and “professionalism” that the university expected of its faculty.  The faculty member interpreted that letter as an attempt to invoke the university’s Computer Usage Policy, which prohibited “any communication which tends to embarrass or humiliate any member of the community.”  The faculty member challenged that policy on First Amendment grounds, arguing that, on its face, the policy infringed on their free speech rights.

The Court agreed with the faculty member, at least at the summary judgment stage of the case.  The Court noted that the language of the Computer Usage Policy was similar to other language in university speech codes that other courts had struck down.  The university argued that its technology resources were a “non-public forum,” which would grant wider leeway for speech restrictions.  The Court, however, found that the university had not made an adequate evidentiary showing that its technology resources were a “non-public forum” and ruled that a jury would ultimately have to decide the issue.

Categorized: First Amendment

Tagged In:

About the Authors

Stay Connected

Partner

Robert G. Young

Bob Young is an experienced advisor and trial lawyer, helping clients navigate complex labor and employment issues and defending employers facing claims in the state and federal courts of Massachusetts and before administrative agencies. Bob regularly represents businesses, municipalities, educational institutions and non-profit organizations of all sizes, as well as high-level executives, in high-exposure claims and disputes involving discrimination and retaliation, non-competition, trade secrets, wage-and-hour and other complex, constantly evolving employment-related issues.

Stay Connected

More Posts by Author ›

About the Authors

Stay Connected

Partner

Robert G. Young

Bob Young is an experienced advisor and trial lawyer, helping clients navigate complex labor and employment issues and defending employers facing claims in the state and federal courts of Massachusetts and before administrative agencies. Bob regularly represents businesses, municipalities, educational institutions and non-profit organizations of all sizes, as well as high-level executives, in high-exposure claims and disputes involving discrimination and retaliation, non-competition, trade secrets, wage-and-hour and other complex, constantly evolving employment-related issues.

Stay Connected

More Posts by Author ›

Stay Connected

Subscribe to Blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.